When I Work Alternative for Businesses That Want to Own Their Time Clock

When I Work is an app for employee scheduling, time tracking and team messaging, priced per user each month. TimeClick is time clock software you install on your own Windows computer and buy once, with unlimited employees on every license. This page compares the two on cost, phone clock-ins and payroll, using each company’s own website. Prices were checked on Nov 16, 2026.

When I Work is built around the schedule. If building shifts and filling open shifts is your main task, it covers that, and TimeClick has no shift scheduling. If you mainly need a time clock and a payroll file, compare the three-year costs below.

When I Work and TimeClick compared in one table

When I Work TimeClick
Pricing model Subscription per user per month, with month-to-month or annual billing One-time license, priced by number of devices
Plans Single location or schedule: $2.50 per user per month. Multiple locations or schedules: $5 per user per month $299 once for 1 device, up to $2,349 for 50 devices
Who counts as a user Everyone who uses When I Work, including managers No user count; employees are unlimited
Time clock Built-in time clock with GPS clock-in, in every plan iPhone and Android app, with a 2-device license or larger and an active TimeClick Unlimited plan; desktop clock on a shared Windows PC
Location checks GPS or geofencing at clock-in Geofencing at clock-in, included at no extra cost today with an active TimeClick Unlimited plan
Scheduling and team messaging Included in every plan No shift scheduling or team chat. A start time can be set for each employee to track late arrivals
Overtime and breaks Overtime and break tracking, paid break tracking, early clock-in prevention Overtime calculated automatically, auto lunch deductions, rounding to 1, 5, 10 or 15 minutes
Payroll Payroll and POS integrations; Rippling is the preferred payroll partner Export files for QuickBooks Desktop, QuickBooks Online, Gusto, ADP Workforce Now and Passport PBS
Free trial 14 days, no credit card 14 days, no credit card

Checked Nov 16, 2026 on When I Work pricing, When I Work integrations and TimeClick pricing.

What When I Work costs

On Nov 16, 2026, When I Work’s pricing page showed two plans, both priced per user per month:

Plan Price What the plan lists
Single location or schedule $2.50 per user per month Scheduling, time tracking and attendance, team messaging, labor reports and forecasts, payroll and POS integrations
Multiple locations or schedules $5 per user per month The same, plus unlimited job sites and locations, labor sharing, custom reporting and role permissions

Managers count as users. The page offers month-to-month or annual billing and does not say which one the listed prices are for. The same page showed a different layout on another visit that day, with three plans and time tracking as an option you switch on, so check the current page for the price you would pay.

What TimeClick costs

TimeClick is a one-time purchase priced by the number of devices. Every license includes unlimited employees and the first year of TimeClick Unlimited (U.S.-based support, new versions and the phone app).

Devices One-time price TimeClick Unlimited renewal after year one
1 (desktop only) $299 $149 a year
2 $499 $199 a year
5 $749 $249 a year
10 $999 $299 a year
15 $1,249 $349 a year
20 $1,499 $379 a year
35 $1,999 $449 a year
50 $2,349 $499 a year

The full list of 10 license sizes is on the pricing page. You can upgrade later by paying the difference between licenses. Renewing TimeClick Unlimited is optional, but the phone app needs it.

How TimeClick counts devices

Each Windows PC that runs TimeClick is one device, and so is each phone or tablet that runs the TimeClick app. Twenty employees clocking in at one shared PC need a 1-device license. One PC plus four phones for staff who work away from the office need a 5-device license.

TimeClick 25 clock screen on a shared PC, with the time, the date and each employee's status

Three-year cost for 10 and 25 users

These totals use the When I Work prices above, counting every user including managers. They do not include taxes.

Option How it is calculated 3-year cost
When I Work, single location, 10 users 10 x $2.50 x 36 months $900
When I Work, single location, 25 users 25 x $2.50 x 36 months $2,250
When I Work, multiple locations, 25 users 25 x $5 x 36 months $4,500
TimeClick, everyone clocks in at one shared PC $299 license, plus $149 a year in years 2 and 3 if you keep TimeClick Unlimited $299 to $597
TimeClick, one PC plus 4 phones $749 license (5 devices), plus $249 a year in years 2 and 3 $1,247
TimeClick, one PC plus 9 phones $999 license (10 devices), plus $299 a year in years 2 and 3 $1,597

Prices checked Nov 16, 2026. When I Work’s price includes scheduling and team messaging, and TimeClick is a time clock. Compare the features you need first, then the price.

When I Work features to check before you switch

When I Work lists these on its pricing and integrations pages. TimeClick’s pages do not list them, so check whether your team uses them:

  • Shift scheduling with auto scheduling, schedule templates, open shifts and shift swapping
  • Team messaging and workplace announcements
  • Labor forecasting and budgeting tools
  • Tips tracking
  • Payroll integrations beyond TimeClick’s five, such as Rippling, Square Payroll, Paychex, OnPay and SimplePay

Where TimeClick is the better fit

  • You want to pay once and stop paying per user.
  • You have many employees on one shared PC, where a 1-device license covers everyone.
  • You want time records kept on your own Windows computer or server.
  • You want desktop clock-ins to keep working when the internet is down.
  • You run payroll in QuickBooks Desktop, ADP Workforce Now or Passport PBS. When I Work’s integrations page lists QuickBooks Online. It does not list QuickBooks Desktop, ADP or Passport.
  • You want support from a U.S.-based team in Utah, included for the first year.

Phone clock-ins and location checks in each product

When I Work’s pricing page lists time and attendance with GPS clock-in in every plan, and its FAQ says employees can clock in using GPS or geofencing.

TimeClick geofencing checks phone clock-ins against the zones you draw around each worksite. Location is checked only at clock-in, so employees are not tracked between punches. Geofencing is included at no extra cost today with an active TimeClick Unlimited plan. The TimeClick phone app runs on iPhone and Android and needs a 2-device license or larger.

Payroll in each product

TimeClick creates export files from Report Center, Payroll Reports, for QuickBooks Desktop, QuickBooks Online, Gusto, ADP Workforce Now and Passport PBS. Exports are included in every license. Overtime is flagged automatically, rounding can be set to 1, 5, 10 or 15 minutes, and lunch deductions are applied before the file is made. See TimeClick payroll integrations.

TimeClick 25 Report Center with Hours Report settings for one pay period and buttons to view the report or save it as CSV or PDF

When I Work’s integrations page lists payroll integrations with Rippling, Gusto, Square Payroll, Paychex, QuickBooks Online, OnPay and SimplePay (for Canadian businesses). Rippling is its preferred payroll partner, and the pricing page offers new customers 6 months of Rippling free.

How to switch from When I Work to TimeClick

  1. Save your employee list and your past timesheet reports from When I Work. Past punches stay in When I Work, so keep its last reports.
  2. Download the 14-day free trial and install TimeClick on the PC that will hold your data.
  3. Import or add your employees and departments.
  4. Set your pay period, rounding, lunch deductions and overtime rules.
  5. Set up phones, crew tablets and geofences if your team clocks in away from the office.
  6. Run both systems for one pay period and compare the hours.
  7. Export the pay period to your payroll system from Report Center, Payroll Reports.
  8. Cancel When I Work after your last payroll from it.
TimeClick 25 Import Employees screen with three steps: download the template, fill in your employees and upload the CSV file

For more on the two pricing models, see buy once vs subscription time clock software.

When I Work alternative FAQ

Is there a When I Work alternative without a monthly fee?

TimeClick is a one-time license from $299 with unlimited employees. The optional TimeClick Unlimited plan renews once a year, from $149 for a 1-device license, and the phone app needs it.

How much does When I Work cost?

On Nov 16, 2026, $2.50 per user per month for a single location or schedule, and $5 per user per month for multiple locations or schedules. Managers count as users.

How does TimeClick compare with When I Work?

When I Work is an app for scheduling, time tracking and team messaging, priced per user each month. TimeClick is a Windows time clock you buy once, with records on your own computer and payroll export files. The table at the top of this page compares them line by line.

Does TimeClick have scheduling like When I Work?

No. TimeClick tracks time. You can set a start time for each employee to see who is late.

Can employees clock in from their phones?

Yes, with the TimeClick app for iPhone and Android, on a 2-device license or larger with an active TimeClick Unlimited plan. Each phone counts as one device.

Does TimeClick work without internet?

The desktop clock does. If a phone can’t reach your TimeClick server, its punches are saved on the phone until it reconnects.

Try TimeClick for 14 days

Install TimeClick on your office PC, add your team and run one pay period. No credit card is needed.